Pray the Gay Away: Chapter 10

[amuly]

Title: Pray the Gay Away: Chapter 10
Pairing: Sirius/Remus
Word Count: 2,986
Rating: R
Summary: Remus' parents send him to a Christian camp designed to help him control his “Same Sex Attraction”. Once there, Remus finds himself rooming with the devilishly handsome bad-boy, Sirius Black. Will he give in to temptation? Could the attraction he feels for Sirius be more than physical? Non-Magical 1970s AU
Chapter Summary: We find out what was in that paper bag.
Warnings: intercrural sex, foodplay, blowjobs (barely), some slight groddy sex squick, but only discussed.
A/N: THEY JUST WOULDN'T HAVE SEX. Oh my gosh. I don't know what the fuck the boys were doing during this whole chapter, but it took them forever to get around to the sexy!timez! I apologize on their behalf.
Side note: PLOT will resume next chapter. The boys deserved a break, you know? :P

NB: Dear British readers: it has come to my attention that you are ignorant as to the awesome of s'mores. I offer you a picture, and beg artistic license for what goes on in this chapter :P.

Previous Chapters:
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9

 

That night, Remus was squirming with anticipation. They had finished up their last activity for the day, and the counselors were calling for lights out around the cabins, strolling between them for one last check-in. Remus and Sirius were sitting at their desks, studiously bent over their Bibles when the counselor came in. He didn't check on what they were writing, just said goodnight and shut the door. Remus grinned as he tucked away a lewd note Sirius had just passed him.

“Surprise time?”

Sirius' grin was all the answer Remus needed. Touching at his arm, Sirius maneuvered Remus to his bed and had him sit and wait, going so far as to make Remus close his eyes. Remus obeyed, smiling into the kiss Sirius gave him before he vanished, random sounds from around the cabin Remus' only clue that he was still there.

He kept his eyes shut for several minutes, listening to the sounds of the paper bag being rummaged through, then being torn apart. Remus heard Sirius' lighter go once, and he thought he could feel some soft heat coming from the center of the room. There was the crinkling of something that sounded like chocolate wrappers – though Remus couldn't be sure – and some other rustlings from other containers. Finally, Remus felt Sirius touch his arm lightly. “Okay. Open your eyes.”

His eyes flickered immediately to the center of the floor, where there was a soft, flickering light. Sirius had set up a small, portable stove, complete with a tiny, contained campfire and grill. It looked like something garden gnomes might use.

The tearing he had heard earlier was the paper bag, which Sirius had torn up and tacked over the window. Sirius saw Remus looking at it and winked. “So no curious counselors will interrupt us because they thought there was a fire.”

But the absolute best, best part of the whole thing was what was carefully laid out next to the campfire, in neat little piles. “S'mores?” Remus gasped and dropped down to the floor. Sirius joined him, expectantly grinning.

“And it's your favorite type of chocolate.” Sirius proffered the chocolate wrapper to Remus as proof.

Remus found he could do nothing more than clutch the chocolate wrapper to his chest, overwhelmed by the gesture. After the silence stretched on too long, Sirius reached a hesitant hand to him. “Is it... is it alright? I thought...”

“Sirius,” Remus breathed. At a loss for words, he reached out and grabbed Sirius' extended hand, drawing the other boy to him. They kissed, Sirius making a pleased little sound in the back of his throat.

“Good, then?” Sirius asked breathlessly. Remus only laughed and nodded back in response. “Want to get sweet and sticky with me then, Remus?”

Laughing again, Remus snogged Sirius once more for good measure – and because he could. Almost reluctantly they pulled apart, Remus glancing down at the careful stacks of marshmallows, graham crackers, and chocolate. “I think this might be the first time in my life I've had difficulty choosing between chocolate and something else.”

Sirius waggled his eyebrows lewdly, scooting away from Remus on the floor and reaching for a stick and a marshmallow. “Well, this time you get to have both. And since I'll keep for another hour, but this fire won't, I vote for chocolate first, me second.”

With a shy smile, Remus held up one of the – many – spare bars of chocolate. “Could we try both?”

Sirius' mouth was already full of half-baked marshmallow, but he still managed a sticky grin. “Mmf!”

Ultimately, Remus decided that the s'mores idea was quite an excellent one, and that he really should have at least one normal s'more before he and Sirius started getting creative with them. Sirius managed to inhale three in the time it took Remus to carefully construct a single one, though Remus largely attributed that to Sirius' impatience when it came to roasting marshmallows. He would hold them in the fire for all of ten seconds before yanking them out and squeezing them between two graham crackers.

Finished with his one s'more and fingers carefully licked clean (which had ended up involving a lot more staring and eyes and heavy breathing than Remus had realized it would incite at first), Remus tugged at one of the spare bars of chocolate. Gingerly it held it over the small fire, careful to melt one end and not the other. When half the bar was satisfactorily melty, he curled one finger at Sirius. “C'mere.”

Sirius was in his lap before he could think twice, staring eagerly at the chocolate clutched gingerly between Remus' fingers. Uncertain what exactly to do – it wasn't like he had ever done this before, after all – Remus took a single chocolate-covered finger and smeared it over Sirius' lips. Sirius – more practiced and willing to take the lead – leaned in and kissed Remus, letting him lap at the melted chocolate and spreading it over twining tongues. Remus moaned happily at the dual sensation. Oh yes. This was an excellent idea. Now he just had to figure out where else he wanted to taste chocolate on Sirius.

“What... where else should I...?”

Sirius, evidently taking this as his cue to end the first part of their date and begin the second, quickly stamped out their fire and tucked the supplies out of the way. Next, he whipped his clothes off, until he was lying spread out and starkers on Remus' bed before Remus even had time to react.

Well, before most of Remus had time to react. One part of Remus was reacting quite rapidly to the sight before him.

“Ung...”

Sirius nodded down at his own chest. “You don't have to do anything you don't want. But I was thinking you could spread the chocolate around? Chest, nipples, stomach, bellybutton...” Remus' entire body flushed as Sirius trailed off. His eyes were following the path Sirius' words were taking him, and he was well-aware of where that led.

One deep, shuddering breath later, and Remus was crawling on top of Sirius on the small camp bed. He took a second to set the half-melted chocolate bar down on Sirius' chest while he quickly shucked his clothes off. Sirius was grinning up at him, hips shifting on their own as the two boys squirmed against each other.

Finally Remus was settled snugly on top of Sirius. He picked up the chocolate bar and began dabbing it on the points Sirius mentioned: his nipples, his navel. Remus took a moment to make little dots of chocolate in a path between the three points. Hesitating, Remus glanced shyly down at Sirius' erection. The chocolate was rapidly cooling, so ultimately it was expediency that forced his hand: Remus quickly traced a line of chocolate up the underside of Sirius' cock, before dabbing lightly at the precome on top. Sirius shuddered and twitched beneath him at the touch, though Remus kept his eyes averted. He was still a bit embarrassed, even in their state of mutual nudity and arousal.

The used candy bar was discarded over the edge of the bed, and Remus absently sucked the chocolate off his fingers as he considered the naked, chocolate-covered boy beneath him. Sirius made a plaintive, whiny noise, nodding at his fingers. “Let me help with that,” he murmured. Remus' eyes widened at Sirius' “seduction voice”, and found himself proffering his fingers without question to Sirius' questing mouth.

The other boy flicked his tongue out first, lapping lightly at the chocolate-covered fingers before growing more insistent, wrapping his tongue around them and sucking them into his mouth. Remus' mouth fell open and a moan escaped as he watched Sirius' cheeks hollow and his red lips purse around his fingers. His tongue was lapping at the fingers in his mouth, leaving no square millimeter of flesh un-laved. Remus' head swam with the attention.

Sirius released Remus' fingers gently, licking and kissing at them even as he allowed them to fall from his mouth. It took Remus a few seconds to remember where he was and what he was supposed to be doing, but then he was kissing Sirius, tasting chocolate on his tongue. Remus turned his mouth from Sirius', focusing on kissing his way down his jaw, neck, and chest. When he reached the first chocolate-covered nipple, it was after only a moment's pondering that Remus bent his head and sucked the little nub into his mouth. Sirius hummed happily, hand going down to tangle in Remus' short brown hair.

Satisfied that the chocolate was gone from one, Remus turned his attention to the other nipple, sucking and licking at that until it was clean. On instinct, Remus finished by scraping his teeth gently over the hardened nub. He was rewarded by a cry from Sirius and his hand tightening in his hair. “'s good, Remus.”

Following the trail he had made for himself in chocolate, Remus dipped his tongue into Sirius' navel. The other boy's stomach contracted and rolled beneath Remus' lips. Fascinated by the response, Remus drew his lips back to observe the movements. Sirius whined and tugged at his hair playfully. “Somewhere you want me to be?”

Sirius shot Remus a lusty look, tugging at his hair again. “If you don't... want...” Sirius' chest was heaving as he tried to reassure Remus.

Although his stomach flipped and squirmed at the thought of doing to Sirius what Sirius had already to him multiple times, Remus steeled himself and leaned down. Hands shaking, Remus placed them on Sirius' thighs to steady himself. His tongue darted out once, twice, before finally flicking against Sirius' shaft on the third try. Above him, Sirius groaned. Remus took this as encouragement to go again, so he pushed his tongue out and licked at the stripe of chocolate he had painted on the underside of Sirius' erection. He could taste Sirius' skin beneath the dark, bitter taste of the chocolate. Sirius' groin smelled musky, and Remus carefully catalogued the differing sensations in his mind.

Growing in confidence – due in large part to Sirius' panting and writing above him – Remus reached a hand up from Sirius' thighs and gripped at the base of his erection. Sirius had done this enough times to him that Remus understood the basics of what to do. With careful precision, Remus lowered his mouth over the head and moved down.

“Remus,” Sirius hissed, tugging at Remus' hair. He glanced up, frowning. “Cover your teeth. Like this.” Sirius demonstrated, lips going to cover his teeth in imitation of an old man.

Remus pulled away and blushed. “Sorry, I'm... sorry. Never done this before...”

Sirius' hand was cool on his cheek as he brushed at the flushed cheekbone there. “It's alright. I know. Honestly,” Sirius hauled himself up onto his elbows so he could look down at Remus, “I like that you haven't done a lot of stuff, 'cause I get to be all sorts of firsts for you.”

Remus swore his face grew even more red, and he glanced down, only to be confronted by the sight of Sirius' throbbing, veiny penis. Okay, so not the place to look. He shifted his eyes to the blanket they were lying on. “Is... was something like that in the bag. Um...” he glanced back up at Sirius before looking away again. “Lube?” he finally managed to whisper.

Sirius laughed and tugged at Remus' shoulder, pulling him up his body. Remus went willingly, smiling as their bodies fit together so easily. He had begun rethinking his biological argument against homosexuality: his and Sirius' bodies always slid together so perfectly, that there was no way nature never intended for this to happen. She certainly hadn't tried very hard to stop them.

“No lube. I figured you wouldn't want to, yet.” He tossed a thumb over his shoulder jokingly. “Though if you do, I'll go get James right now: run the whole way there and back.”

Remus shook his head, laughing. Sirius always knew how to make him feel better: more at ease. “No. I'm... well, nervous. You know.” He frowned, hand unconsciously stroking at Sirius' thigh. “I heard it hurts. A lot. And there was tearing and blood. But I don't know what's true and what's, you know: camp counselors.”

Face gone serious, the other boy nodded. “It can. If you're rough 'n don't care about the other guy. And if you don't use lube.” Craning his neck, Sirius placed little kisses to Remus' shoulder and collar bone. “But I'd never hurt you. The first time, we'll just take it nice and slow. So long as I stretch you out, you stay relaxed, and I use a lot of lube, it'll be okay.” Sirius nuzzled his nose against Remus' chest, licking a playful stripe across the smooth skin. “And I'll make sure you love every minute of it.”

They kissed, and Remus relaxed into it, forgetting about his inadequacies at blowjobs and nervousness over penetration. He laughed when he felt Sirius' sticky penis slide over his, glancing down between them to see the chocolate smearing across their thighs and groins. Sirius glanced down with him, wrinkling his nose at the sight. “Give it a few months, and you'll be as grossed out as I am at the way that looks.”

Pondering what he meant, Remus stared down at his groin as Sirius wet a t-shirt of his and proceeded to clean them off. He supposed the chocolate smeared around sort of looked like... and he or Sirius would be shoving his cock up... “Ew! Does that happen?!”

Sirius shrugged, tossing the used t-shirt away over his shoulder. “Sometimes, a little bit. If you're careful...” Sirius stopped upon meeting Remus' horrified gaze. “Can we talk about the specifics of it all when we actually get around to it?”

Remus nodded, but mentally he was revising his biological arguments. Nature: 1, him and Sirius: 1. That bitch.

Sirius' mouth sucking at his collarbone successfully distracted Remus from his mental tally, and soon their hips were sliding smoothly together, getting sticky with precome rather than chocolate. Nudging at Remus' chin, Sirius looked up at him with big eyes. “Turn on your side?”

Remus didn't even ask. He trusted Sirius.

Once on his side, Remus heard Sirius spit into his palm and felt his fist bumping against Remus' leg as he stroked at his cock. Then Sirius was gently nudging the head of his erection against Remus' thighs, begging entrance. After a moment of awkwardness, Remus figured out how to spread his thighs enough for Sirius to slide in, then squeeze them tightly enough for Sirius enjoy the friction it caused.

“This is the Greek method,” Sirius murmured against Remus' neck. His lips pressed little kisses to the short hairs there between sentences. “This way, it's almost like we're doing it, but we can do this without lube and you won't get hurt.”

Remus grunted his satisfaction as Sirius slipped a hand over his hip and began stroking him in time with his thrusts. Feeling Sirius' erection between his thighs was arousing – exciting, even. It felt like Sirius was so close to having sex with him without taking that final step. Remus whimpered as he thrust into Sirius' tight fist. It felt good. Really good.

Sirius' thrust grew harder and faster, hand tugging in a stuttering rhythm along with them. Remus' body jerked with every thrust, and he shuddered. He could imagine this might be how it would be like to have sex, real sex, with Sirius: thrusting, and grunting, and trembling bodies spiraling closer and closer toward... Behind him, Sirius made a strangled little choked-off sound, before Remus felt him stiffen and warm come spread between his thighs. A moment later, Sirius' hand reached down to dip into the sticky liquid, before wrapping it around Remus' cock and continuing pumping it. With the added slick, Remus came a few seconds later, stars bursting behind his eyes as he curled around Sirius' arm.

As he came down, Remus shifted and turned until he was hugging Sirius tightly to his chest. Remus felt sleepy and satisfied, and wanted nothing more than to fall asleep in Sirius' arms. Then they shifted on the bed into a more comfortable position, and Remus found his thigh pressed down onto a wet spot on the sheets. “Ew.” Remus twisted and looked down between them, wrinkling his nose. “Wet spot.”

Sirius was even more boneless than he was, long arms and legs draped around him. “Nnf.”

“Sirius, come on. I don't want to sleep on the wet spot.”

“S'moof.”

Remus blinked, before coming to the understanding that Sirius meant “So move”. At least, so Remus could only assume. “No, Sirius, come on: the bed's too small. And this is gross. I don't want to sleep on top of your come.”

Remus was fairly certain the next sound out of Sirius' mouth was a snore.

“Oh, for...” With a sigh, Remus hauled Sirius into his lap and slid slowly off the bed, carrying him the one step it took to cross the room to Sirius' (relatively) fresh, clean bed. In his arms, Sirius made a sound that sounded suspiciously like a giggle. Remus glared down at him before tossing him onto his bed. Sirius resolutely kept his eyes closed, moving only to curl himself around Remus when he crawled into bed beside Sirius. Dry and satisfied, Remus barely had time to pull the covers up before he fell asleep, head nestled in the crook of Sirius' shoulder.


Continue onto Chapter 11.